Should I Remove My Swimming Pool? Insights into Swimming Pool Demolition

Homeowners often grapple with the decision to remove their swimming pools, especially when considering the costs, potential benefits, and the impact on property value and usability. Swimming pool demolition might seem like a drastic measure, but it can also offer a number of advantages, depending on your circumstances and lifestyle. This article explores the various factors to consider when deciding whether to remove a swimming pool from your property.

Reasons for Considering Swimming Pool Demolition

1. Costs of Maintenance: One of the primary reasons homeowners consider pool removal is the ongoing cost of maintenance. Keeping a swimming pool in good shape involves regular cleaning, chemical balancing, and equipment maintenance. For some, the time and expense required to maintain a pool can become overwhelming, especially if the pool is infrequently used.
2. Safety Concerns: Families with small children or pets might view a pool as a safety hazard. In the U.S., drowning is the second leading cause of unintentional injury death for children ages 1-14 years, according to the CDC. Removing a pool can reduce these risks significantly, offering peace of mind to concerned parents or pet owners.
3. Space Utilization: Swimming pools take up a significant portion of yard space. If your lifestyle would benefit more from a garden, an expanded lawn, or a patio area for entertaining, demolishing a pool could free up valuable outdoor living space.
4. Insurance and Liability: Owning a swimming pool can increase homeowners’ insurance costs due to liability risks. Removing a pool may decrease your insurance premiums and reduce the potential for liability concerns associated with pool accidents.
5. Selling Your Home: While a pool can be an attractive feature in some markets, in others it could decrease the likelihood of a sale. Prospective buyers might view it as an unwanted expense and responsibility. Removing a pool could make your property more appealing to a broader range of buyers.

The Process of Swimming Pool Demolition

Swimming pool demolition is a significant undertaking that generally involves two main methods: partial removal and complete removal.

• Partial Removal: Also known as a pool fill-in, this method involves breaking down the top portion of the pool structure (usually about 18-36 inches) and then filling in the pool with gravel and soil. While less expensive, this method can lead to issues with drainage and soil settlement over time.
• Complete Removal: This method involves removing all pool materials, including concrete, fiberglass, liners, and surrounding decking. The entire area is then filled in. This option is more expensive but is preferred for those planning significant landscaping or construction projects post-demolition.

Considerations Before Demolition

• Regulations and Permits: Most localities require a permit for swimming pool demolition. It’s important to check with your local building department to understand the specific regulations and obtain the necessary permits before proceeding.
• Hiring Professionals: Due to the complexity and safety concerns associated with demolishing a swimming pool, it’s advisable to hire a professional demolition contractor. These experts can ensure that the pool is removed safely and in accordance with local regulations.
• Cost: The cost of swimming pool demolition varies widely depending on the size of the pool, the method of demolition, accessibility, and local labor rates. On average, homeowners might spend anywhere from $5,000 to $15,000 for a complete demolition.
• Future Landscaping Plans: Consider what you will do with the space once the pool is removed. Professional landscaping post-demolition can be costly but necessary to ensure the usability and aesthetics of the former pool area.

The Benefits of Pool Removal

After the removal of a swimming pool, many homeowners find that their property feels larger, is easier to maintain, and offers more usable outdoor space. The removal also eliminates ongoing maintenance costs and reduces safety worries. Furthermore, it can potentially increase the marketability of your home by appealing to a wider array of potential buyers who might not want the responsibility and upkeep associated with a swimming pool.

Conclusion

Deciding whether to remove a swimming pool is a significant decision that depends on various personal and economic factors. By considering the costs of upkeep, safety, usage, and the impact on property value, as well as the process and expenses involved in swimming pool demolition, homeowners can make an informed choice that best suits their needs and lifestyle. Ultimately, the decision should align with your long-term property goals and personal preferences.